Success Stories: Business Litigation
Administrative Trial Verdict: Our firm, working with customs specialist co-counsel obtained a Defendant’s verdict in favor of our client, a federally regulated duty-free company operating at JFK airport. After our client was charged with violations of the NYC Administrative Code, at trial we were able to convince an ALJ to dismiss all charges based upon federal preemption, supremacy, and lack of local jurisdiction. The verdict is one of the first of its kind limiting New York City’s efforts to regulate federally controlled companies.
Lawsuit Dismissed. Our client, a New York LLC, faced a lawsuit seeking dissolution along with breach of fiduciary duty claims against certain members. After motions, on March 21, 2024, the Commercial Division of the NYS Supreme Court dismissed all dissolution and fiduciary duty claims. Peebles v. A&S Legacy LLC et al. Supreme Court, Commercial Division, Nassau County.
After our client obtained a prior judgment against a corporate entity guarantor, we brought an action seeking to pierce the corporate veil and for an order for turnover of restrained funds pursuant to CPLR §5225. After motion practice, the Court granted an Order piercing the corporate veil, directing the turnover of funds, and assigning liability not only to the individual owner of the corporate guarantor but against a successor entity owned by him as well. Summit Glory Property v. Forthright Holdings et al., Supreme Court, Commercial Division, New York County.
On behalf of EVO Merchant Services (now Global Payments) we brought an action (Supreme Court, Suffolk County) against former employees and independent contractors who started a competing business in violation of restrictive covenants. Initially, we obtained a Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary injunction against the Defendants. During the litigation we obtained a contempt order on motion against a recalcitrant non-party and uncovered extensive information about the profits and clients of the competing entity through multistate discovery. The case settled shortly before trial which included restrictive covenants. EVO Merchant Services and Federated Payment Systems, LLC, v. JJL Equity et. al.: Supreme Court, Commercial Division, Suffolk County.
Supreme Court, Commercial Division, Grants Our Motion to Dismiss: Two of our business entity clients were brought into a multi-Defendant lawsuit alleging Breach of Fiduciary Duty, Unjust Enrichment, Breach of a shareholder agreement, and seeking the imposition of a Constructive Trust. The Commercial Division of the Supreme Court granted our Motion to Dismiss as to both our clients. Schwartz v. Velocity et al., Supreme Court, Commercial Division, Nassau County.
On behalf of a payment processor client, we performed an extensive multi-state investigation against a business entity and its guarantor principals suspected of fraud. Based on that investigation we were able to bring an action that included a Civil RICO cause of action detailing the multistate scheme in federal court (E.D.N.Y.). After initial pleadings, the Court directed us to bring a pre-answer motion for partial summary judgment. The case settled shortly after submission of that motion. Prior to and during that litigation we coordinated extensively with out of state prosecutors. Cutter, LLC v. Leuze et. al.: United States District Court, Eastern District of New York.
Our client was sued by Plaintiff who alleged causes of action for aiding and abetting breach of fiduciary duty and tortious interference with contract. The Court granted our motion to dismiss the action against our client pursuant to CPLR §3211. Rockefeller v. AVF Development Supreme et al., Court, Commercial Division, Nassau County.
Our client, the co-owner of a Limited Liability Company owning commercial properties brought a lawsuit against her co-owner and commercial tenant for breach of the provisions of a commercial lease. We obtained an order granting our client Summary Judgment pursuant to CPLR §3212 on her causes of action for breach of contract, and an award of attorney’s fees in addition to a dismissal of Defendants’ counterclaims. Wilans v. Plush, Supreme Court, Commercial Division, Nassau County.
Won summary judgment against commercial customer of engineering firm client based on breach of contract and account stated causes of action. Obtained substantial recovery in collection efforts including the restraint and turnover of seized funds. HM Loke Engineering v. PMM Cranes, Supreme Court, Nassau County.
Obtained Summary Judgment dismissing an action for corporate dissolution and damages brought under Business Corporations Law 1104. (Keisteadt v. Dapeka et al. Commercial Division, Supreme Court, Nassau County)
Won appeal, affirming successful trial court decision (Supreme Court, Nassau County) upholding Plaintiffs’ lawsuit against claim that it constituted a Strategic Lawsuit against Public Participation (SLAPP) under the New York Civil Rights Law. International Shoppes v. At the Airport LLC, et al, NYS Appellate Division, Second Department).
Won arbitrators decision pursuant to American Arbitration Association Proceeding validating actions of members in appointing managing member of Delaware Limited Liability Company and denying relief requested by co-manager.
Won trial verdict obtaining damages, warrant of possession, and attorneys fees in commercial landlord proceeding while also defeating an application for interim relief in the Supreme Court of Nassau County. (Mao Asian Bistro v. Over the Pool Realty, District Court and Supreme Court, Nassau County).
Won Summary Judgment on behalf of holders of Promissory Note against defaulting obligor despite claim of prior discharge in Bankruptcy (Lorenz v. Baker, Supreme Court, Nassau County).
Obtained dismissal of an action after defeating an attempt at summary judgment by a major New York lending institution against an individual loan guarantor. (CIT v. Barnett, Supreme Court, New York County).
Obtained Summary Judgment, including an award of attorney’s fees, on behalf of a private lender payee, jointly and severally against both a corporate maker and individual personal guarantor of a promissory note pursuant to CPLR §3213. (Global Diamond Group v. Specialty Motor Cars, et. al., Commercial Division, Supreme Court, Queens County).
Won dismissal of Surrogates Court action seeking to compel the distribution of corporate stock held by a testamentary trust. (In Re Hirshon, Surrogates Court, Queens County).
Obtained recovery, after motion practice, of a contractual down payment placed by our client, an aircraft parts manufacturer, with a North Carolina vendor. In addition to recovering 100% of the monies due to our client, we also obtained partial recovery of attorney’s fees. (New Generation Aircraft Services v. Luft Spares Inc. et al., Supreme Court, Nassau County).
Obtained Dismissal of Action brought against national bank by mortgagor alleging violations of TILA and RESPA. (Vasquez v. JP Morgan Chase, Supreme Court, Bronx County).
Won a defendant’s trial verdict on behalf of a commercial contractor in an action brought by a former customer alleging construction defects. (Shapiro v. Empire Pools, District Court, Nassau County).
Obtained full recovery for Corporate Officer in action brought pursuant to N.Y. Business Corporations Law 722-724. (Wolfe, v. DMA, Supreme Court, Queens County).
Obtained Summary Judgment in lieu of a complaint for a private lender against a defaulting obligor on a commercial lending agreement. (Giddings v. Gelman, Supreme Court, Nassau County).
Won Summary Judgment in favor of Real Property buyers and secured the return of their down payment as well as judicial termination of the contract of sale based on building code violations issued to the development containing the property. (Colalillo v. Evans, Supreme Court, Nassau County).
Defeated an attempt by national long term disability insurance carrier to change venue from the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York (Hershman v. Unum Provident Insurance Co. 2007 WL 1217271 (S.D.N.Y 2007).
Defeated an attempt at Summary Judgment by a national credit bank against a New York mortgage company and individual loan guarantors based upon statutes governing commercial lease agreements under the New Jersey Uniform Commercial Code. (Canon Financial v. Cass Bros., Supreme Court, Nassau County)

